Used Tesla Model S for Sale in New York City Metro
27 local listings · median $19,750 · 25 sold in 30 days
Local market overview
There are currently 27 used Tesla Model S listings for sale in the New York City Metro area on OwneDeals, aggregated from Tesla Certified Pre-Owned inventory, partner dealers, and private sellers. The median local asking price is $19,750, with most listings between $15,872 and $51,847, and the average odometer reading is 94,284 miles.
Over the last 30 days, 25 used Tesla Model Ss sold in the New York City Metro market at a median sold price of $55,794, spending about 30 days listed before selling.
Market analysis — used Tesla Model S in New York City Metro
New York City Metro Model S pricing splits between older $15,748-$17,347 cars and newer $43,900-$52,297 stock.
- Active listings
- 29 listings
- Median ask price
- $20,997
- Median sold price
- $55,794
- Avg mileage
- 90,462 miles
New York City Metro's Model S market is not well described by the overall median alone. Today's $20,997 median ask sits beside older-year medians of $17,347 for 2016 and $15,748 for 2017, while 2021 and 2022 asks are $43,900 and $52,297. Recent transactions are concentrated higher, with a $55,794 median sold price and a 2021 sold median of $48,697 versus a $43,900 ask median. With 29 active listings, 29 recent sales, an average of 33 days listed, and 90,462 average miles, shoppers in New York City Metro should compare year, mileage, and trim together before using the headline median as a benchmark.
- Recent sales sit above today's asks: In New York City Metro, the median sold price over the last 30 days was $55,794, versus a current median ask of $20,997. The same pattern appears within 2021 cars, where the median sold price was $48,697 against a median ask of $43,900, with an ask-vs-sold delta of -$4,797.
- Older and newer Model S listings are far apart: The year splits are wide in New York City Metro. Median asks are $17,347 for 2016 and $15,748 for 2017, then jump to $43,900 for 2021 and $52,297 for 2022. The summary's middle price band runs from $15,999 to $50,800.
- Inventory is moving, but not instantly: Supply and recent sales are balanced at 29 active listings and 29 sales in the last 30 days. Even so, the average Model S listing is on the market for 33 days, so some New York City Metro inventory is lingering rather than turning immediately.
- Mileage adds another filter in NYC Metro: Average mileage on active New York City Metro Model S listings is 90,462 miles. Because the market's median ask is $20,997 while 2021 and 2022 asks reach $43,900 and $52,297, mileage is worth comparing alongside year before treating two listings as direct substitutes.
Bottom line: In New York City Metro, the $20,997 median ask masks a split Model S market, so compare 2016-2017 cars separately from 2021-2022 stock.
AI-generated summary of the data shown on this page, last updated 2026-10-05. Figures are directional, not an appraisal.
Median asking price — New York City Metro (last 30 days)
| Week | Median asking price |
|---|---|
| Sep 07 | $19,750 |
| Sep 14 | $19,750 |
| Sep 21 | $23,000 |
| Sep 28 | $35,500 |
| Oct 05 | $19,750 |
Price by model year — New York City Metro
| Model year | Median asking | Active listings | Median sold |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2016 | $17,347 | 6 | None |
| 2017 | $15,748 | 5 | None |
| 2022 | $53,794 | 5 | None |
Price vs. mileage — New York City Metro
What’s available — Model S trims in New York City Metro
| Trim | Active listings |
|---|---|
| Model S All-Wheel Drive | 9 |
| Plaid | 6 |
| 75D | 6 |
| 75 | 2 |
| 100D | 2 |
| 90D | 1 |
| Model S Long Range | 1 |
Shop all used Tesla Model S listings in New York City Metro
Browse every used Tesla Model S for sale in New York City Metro on OwneDeals → Filter by price, mileage, range, Autopilot hardware (HW3 / HW4), and trim.
About this data
Methodology: figures cover the New York City Metro metro (a curated group of local cities). Active-listing statistics reflect vehicles marked for sale when this page was generated. Recently-sold figures use each listing’s last-updated timestamp as a sold-date proxy and are directional market signal, not an appraisal. Trend data comes from OwneDeals’ own inventory snapshots.
Research by DK · OwneDeals Research.