Used Tesla Model Y for Sale in New York City Metro
164 local listings · median $30,648 · 325 sold in 30 days
Local market overview
There are currently 164 used Tesla Model Y listings for sale in the New York City Metro area on OwneDeals, aggregated from Tesla Certified Pre-Owned inventory, partner dealers, and private sellers. The median local asking price is $30,648, with most listings between $24,998 and $36,224, and the average odometer reading is 67,365 miles.
Over the last 30 days, 325 used Tesla Model Ys sold in the New York City Metro market at a median sold price of $34,900, spending about 19 days listed before selling.
Market analysis — used Tesla Model Y in New York City Metro
New York City Metro Model Y sold prices are running above current asks in most model years.
- Active listings
- 168 listings
- Median ask price
- $29,985
- Median sold price
- $34,747
- Avg days listed
- 21 days
In the New York City Metro, the live Model Y market is priced below recent closed sales: the median ask is $29,985, versus a $34,747 median sold price. That gap is most pronounced in 2021 and 2022, where sold medians of $29,794 and $30,350 sit above asks of $22,995 and $26,700; 2023 is much closer at $34,407 asked and $34,800 sold. The exception is 2020, where the median ask of $27,194 is above the $24,993 sold median. Inventory is also trim-heavy, with 123 of 168 listings in Long Range All-Wheel Drive, so shoppers looking at Performance or rear-wheel-drive examples are working with thinner local selection. Current asks span from $24,996 to $35,800 and average 67,935 miles, which makes year and trim more reliable filters than a single headline price.
- Sold comps sit above live asks: Across the New York City Metro, the median active ask is $29,985 while the median sold price is $34,747. With 314 recent sales against 168 active listings, closed-sale comps deserve more weight than headline list prices here.
- 2021 and 2022 show the widest gaps: For 2021 Model Ys in the New York City Metro, the median ask is $22,995 and the median sold price is $29,794, an ask-vs-sold delta of -$6,799. For 2022, the median ask is $26,700 versus $30,350 sold, with a delta of -$3,650.
- 2023 is near parity; 2020 is the exception: The 2023 market is much tighter, with a $34,407 median ask and a $34,800 median sold price, a delta of -$393. By contrast, 2020 is the only year where asks run above sold comps, at $27,194 asked versus $24,993 sold, a delta of $2,201.
- Inventory is concentrated in Long Range AWD: Long Range All-Wheel Drive accounts for 123 of the 168 active New York City Metro listings. Performance All-Wheel Drive is the next-largest bucket at 29, while Model Y Rear-Wheel Drive shows 7.
- Current asks cover a wide band: The middle half of active asks runs from $24,996 to $35,800 around a median of $29,985. Those listings average 67,935 miles, so comparing by year and trim is important before treating any one asking price as a metro-wide benchmark.
Bottom line: In the New York City Metro, recent Model Y sales at $34,747 are above today’s $29,985 median ask, so use year-specific sold comps.
AI-generated summary of the data shown on this page, last updated 2026-10-05. Figures are directional, not an appraisal.
Median asking price — New York City Metro (last 30 days)
| Week | Median asking price |
|---|---|
| Sep 07 | $32,200 |
| Sep 14 | $31,900 |
| Sep 21 | $31,480 |
| Sep 28 | $31,493 |
| Oct 05 | $31,561 |
Price by model year — New York City Metro
| Model year | Median asking | Active listings | Median sold |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2020 | $25,748 | 5 | $25,196 |
| 2021 | $22,747 | 34 | $29,950 |
| 2022 | $25,372 | 32 | $29,900 |
| 2023 | $33,994 | 63 | $35,200 |
| 2024 | $36,400 | 21 | $38,950 |
| 2025 | $36,294 | 3 | $39,550 |
| 2026 | $45,646 | 6 | $46,600 |
Price vs. mileage — New York City Metro
What’s available — Model Y trims in New York City Metro
| Trim | Active listings |
|---|---|
| Long Range All-Wheel Drive | 116 |
| Performance All-Wheel Drive | 33 |
| Model Y Rear-Wheel Drive | 9 |
| Model Y All-Wheel Drive | 3 |
| Long Range Rear-Wheel Drive | 2 |
| Other | 1 |
Shop all used Tesla Model Y listings in New York City Metro
Browse every used Tesla Model Y for sale in New York City Metro on OwneDeals → Filter by price, mileage, range, Autopilot hardware (HW3 / HW4), and trim.
About this data
Methodology: figures cover the New York City Metro metro (a curated group of local cities). Active-listing statistics reflect vehicles marked for sale when this page was generated. Recently-sold figures use each listing’s last-updated timestamp as a sold-date proxy and are directional market signal, not an appraisal. Trend data comes from OwneDeals’ own inventory snapshots.
Research by DK · OwneDeals Research.